Wednesday, September 29, 2010

Cleaning Larry's Blog House

Since I started this blog in the spring, I managed to pontificate 51 times on quite a few exhilirating macro topics. So I realized it was time to do a little house clearing. I created 20 topics for the 51 posts. In this way, if you are totally insane and bored and if you want to see what I have written about unemployment -- you will find all my posts neatly gathered together under a topic called Employment and Unemployment. If you want to revisit my blather about the Fed and other central banks -- you can find the topic Monetary Policy. If you want to learn more about the sex practices of gophers then I suggest you try Wikopedia since I have no posts on that topic. But if I do learn something and want to write about it, I will happily create as many new topics as necessary.

To find the list of topics and associated posts -- go to the main page of the blog and then scroll down and down and down and look in the lower right hand corner...to a box labelled Labels. There is an indicator next to each topic which tells you how many posts can be found under that topic. If you cannot find it, mix up your best margarita, drink it, and then try again in 15 minutes. If that doesn't work after several tries then at least you will have an entertaining evening. I epsecially like Carnitas at LaTorre -- they go very well with margaritas.

Tuesday, September 28, 2010

Do we love debt or do we love spending? It makes a policy difference

In my Myopic Squirrel post I focused on over-spending and I concluded with the following, “Clearly all this spending reduces the nation’s saving and its ability – like the squirrel – to do what’s best for the future.” While spending and saving are two sides of the same coin, it helps to put spending/saving changes into perspective by focusing now on the saving side. To continue the squirrel analogy (is this driving you up a tree?) I find in this post that it might NOT be so much that squirrels want to over-eat in the Fall  – it is more like nuts have become too easy to find and chew.  Does the American consumer want to buy more or do they buy more because credit is so much easier to obtain than it used to be? 

Household saving will be my focus in this post but it is good to remind you that it is just one part of a nation’s saving – which includes saving by households, businesses, and federal, state, and local governments.  Right now the government is a massive dis-saver so solving the household saving problem won’t guarantee a return to normalcy. But you have to start somewhere to build the full story.

While squirrels are fun to watch and talk about (no offense intended to woodchucks and next-door-neighbors) they illustrate the general notion that if a nation doesn’t save enough today it may starve itself tomorrow. In Macro courses we emphasize two problems caused by insufficient saving. First, a low level of saving means that a business firm will find it more difficult and more costly to gain credit to purchase new capital and equipment.  If this goes on for years, then firms will reduce how much they spend on productivity enhancement and this will slow output growth, raise prices, and harm competitiveness.  Second, if lower national saving is insufficient for investment spending, foreign money will flow into the country to augment it. This process tends to raise the value of the dollar and increase the country’s trade deficit.  Whether you focus on the first or second point – the result is a general reduction in domestic and international competitiveness and a slower growing economy. In a nutshell, domestic saving adequacy is very important!

I start by reviewing what most of us know – the saving rate in the USA has fallen dramatically over the years.  To make valid comparisons over time, we look at the ratio of saving to disposable income (income less taxes). In 1952 the personal saving rate was 8.4%. That is, of the amount of after-tax income that we can choose to spend or save, households saved 8.4%. If you take the time period from 1952 to approximately 1988, the saving rate varied quite a bit but stayed in a band of between about 6.9% and 10.7%. It averaged about 9%. After about 1988 the saving rate started on a downward trend. Starting at 10.9% in 1982 it generally fell until bottoming at 1.4% in 2005. The rate recovered and was 5.9% in 2009. The rate has gone in the right direction since 2005 but it appears that temporary factors are at work.  For example, we will show below how important debt is to our calculation of saving rates. As households walked away from mortgages and other debts and as other families paid down their debts, this led to the increase in recent saving rates. But those debt pay-downs can only last so long.  In sum, the following table describes the average annual saving rate since 1952. If 8% is considered a normal rate for the US, then the pattern since 1998 is to be well below that rate.
                1952 to 1970       8.2%
                1970 to 1982       9.8%
                1982 to 1998       6.7%
                1998 to 2007       2.8%
                2007 to 2009       5.0%

There are many sociological and economic explanations for this distinct trend change in saving behavior. We can, perhaps, pursue some of those in a coming post. Here, I want to focus on what we can learn by looking deeper into the components of saving.  Luckily the government calculates saving in two ways. The first and most popular way is what I explained above – saving equals income minus taxes minus spending.  This is often called the NIPA definition of saving where NIPA stands for National Income and Product Accounts. 

The second definition of saving focuses on the uses or forms of saving. It is called the FFA or Flow of Funds Accounts definition of saving and it is published by the Federal  Reserve.  Data for both NIPA and FFA can be found at http://www.bea.gov/national/nipaweb/Nipa-Frb.asp   . These two measures of saving can sometimes differ. For example, in 2000, the NIPA Personal Saving Rate was  2.9% while the FFA version was -2.4%. That’s a big difference. But I don’t want to emphasize the differences. Graphing both series from 1952 to 2009 shows the same general patterns – saving rates rising through 1988 and then falling thereafter.  Both rates show higher saving rates in 2008 and 2009.

The value here in using the FFA Saving series is in what its components tell us. Quoting from A Guide to the NIPAs, “personal saving may be viewed as the net acquisition of financial assets (such as cash and deposits, securities, and the change in life insurance and pension reserves), plus the net investment in produced assets (such as residential housing, less depreciation) less the increase in financial liabilities (such as mortgage debt, consumer credit, and security credit), less net capital transfers received.

That is a mouthful so let’s boil it down to something simple. The FFA Saving figure is a net figure since it looks at how much is being added to or subtracted from what we might call their net worth or net wealth. We say a household has positive net worth if the value of its assets (stocks, bonds, house value, etc) is larger than the value of its liabilities (consumer loans, mortgage loans, etc).  We say there is an increase in Saving in a given year when changes in assets and liabilities imply that the value of its net worth would increase. This could happen if asset contributions increased, liabilities decreased, or if assets increased more than liabilities increased. Accordingly, a nation’s saving falls if the value of assets fall, liabilities rise, or if the assets rise more slowly than liabilities.

The main FFA Personal Saving categories are shown below in the table. Consider the main causes of the high average saving rate between 1952 and 1970 – the net acquisition of assets was almost $80 billion per year while net increase in liabilities (including mortgages) averaged only about$28 billion. The increases in assets was almost 3 times the increase in liabilities. Thus, saving rose. In the next period, the saving rate rose again. Notice that net acquisition of financial and real assets averaged about $348 billion from 1970 to 1982 – greater than a four-fold increase compared to the almost $80 billion in the previous time period. Although liabilities increased by 5.5 times – the value of liabilities was small enough that the effect on saving was swamped by the much larger increase in assets.

You might think that the saving rate would have continued increasing after 1982 by virtue of the very large increases in net acquisitions of financial and real assets—at least doubling in 1982 to 1998 and then again in 1998 to 2007. But it didn’t because the value of liabilities was catching up with the assets. The net increase in liabilities averaged over a trillion dollars during 1998 to 2007 – a huge increase compared to 1982 to 1998. A large part of that swing was attributable to increasing mortgage debt – but at least 40% of that increase in household debt beyond the financing of homes.

Here is one way to summarize and gain perspective on what happened to saving over the last 55 years, much of this since 1982. While personal incomes grew about 42 times and assets held increased about 40 times – liabilities grew by 97 times (mortgage liabilities 104 times).

So we see two things going on in the US.  Consumer spending is growing very fast relative to disposable income and we see households taking on much more in the way of mortgage and other debt.  My father, a product of the Great Depression, bought our home in Miami in 1950 with cash.  But the baby boom generation started a trend of buying houses and other things with credit. Did the desire for housing create a love for credit – or was it something in the acceptance and love of credit that created a spending and housing boom? The way you answer these questions underpins how you approach the problem. For example, in my Squirrels post I suggested that households would need to cut $840 billion annually from future spending. Do we constrain spending by using policy to reward saving? Or do we restrain spending by making credit harder to obtain? Or do we do both?
52 to 70
70 to 82
82 to 98
98 to 07
07 to 09
Saving Rate NIPA
8.2
9.8
6.7
2.8
5.0
  Net acquisition of financial assets
43.9
236.8
525.0
940.3
261.1
  Plus: Net investment in tangible assets
35.9
107.3
277.9
671.2
296.0
  Less: Net increase in liabilities
27.9
151.5
370.3
1263.7
-161.2
    Mortgage debt on nonfarm homes
12.7
64.5
198.5
761.5
-146.5

Monday, September 27, 2010

How do you define a humane stimulus package?

I had planned another post for today but I just can’t ignore the news. As I write, the DJ Average is down more than 200 points. But this post isn’t really about the stock market. What I am writing about is three news items today. First, in a special session that prevented our nation’s leaders from their August recess (doesn’t the word recess remind you of what first graders do at 10 in the morning?) added another $26 billion to government spending. Second, the Fed formally announced its decision to downgrade their forecasts of coming US economic growth. They agreed to a small amount of further monetary stimulus (called QE or quantitative easing) and implied that more might be needed. Third, Laurence Kotlikoff wrote that the US is financially bankrupt. He puts up some scary numbers about what it would take to close the federal government fiscal gap. Clearly he is arguing against further fiscal stimulus. http://noir.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601010&sid=aiFjnanrDWVk

Take the first two items. They are evidence that the dominant policy opinion is the seemingly humane one – more stimulus. Public Enemy #1 is slow growth that is too weak to provide significantly higher employment. It appears we are in a vicious cycle – low employment means low spending which means low employment. Monetary or fiscal stimulus aims to increase spending. But is this really humane? On the surface of it – it looks as if it is. Putting school teachers back to work not only improves the education process but it means one more family will be adding spending to the economy.

But is this really humane? What if most workers see the stimulus for what it really is – a drastic and panicky attempt to revive an economy with multiple fundamental problems, none of which is too little government spending or money growth. What if school teachers or whoever gets assisted by the latest package – and everyone else – see these actions as a sure sign that things are going to get worse before they get better? My guess is that most of them will save as much as they can of their newfound incomes – many will pay off their horrible credit card debts – many will abandon house payments. Hmmm – this does not sound so humane to me. It INSURES THAT THE DOWNSPIN will continue. We know this exactly because most experts agree that the lack of spending right now is a result of negative expectations and uncertainty. These last ditch fire hoses do nothing but enflame the uncertainty. Shame on you Fed. Shame on you Congress! Humane indeed!

My Keynesian friend says there is plenty of evidence of past stimulus policies working. And I would agree that there have been times and places when some stimulus was necessary and did work. A couple of years ago some stimulus was useful – but even then I argued that too much stimulus would send the wrong message – it sent a message of severe alarm. The Sky is Falling is what I heard. And that’s the problem today. Piling up even more stimulus sends the wrong message today. It is scaring the crap out of everyone. Furthermore, if Kotlikoff is right, it sends a Grecian message as well. If more people believe that solving the US financial gap will take Herculean increases in taxes and reductions in spending – they will translate this into even more pessimism. Are we giving a teacher a job today only to take it back tomorrow?

Clearly I don’t know the answer. But it seems to me rather than play the populist game of more stimulus, it is possible to spend more time on a plan to attack the real structural problems. We don’t have to actually start the policies today – but we could agree on and enact a proper set of real changes with an agreed schedule that make sense and would give people a little confidence in the future. Why wait until after the fall elections?

It is frustrating to me that the solution is right in front of our faces, yet we dodge it only to flail around with policies that only worsen the situation. The right policies will show that we are smart enough to recognize the true source of our economic problems and tough enough to enact the right policies. Being smart and tough is what we need to install the confidence and optimism necessary to get firms to want to produce more and to hire more workers to do so.

Wednesday, September 22, 2010

The Fed comes out of the closet and slips on a banana peel

The Fed met and made it pretty clear that its monetary policy no longer is aimed at a severe recession, a double dip, or declining economic conditions. Now it says it will step in and buy even more government assets and try to push interest rates lower to support the economic recovery. Hmmm -- now that is news. That muddies the water precisely enough so that the Fed has now lost and remaining credibility.

Since "to support the economic recovery" has never been defined it leaves open a much more active and aggressive policy for the Fed -- and the chances of overdoing it. I know -- there were words in the latest statement about stabilizing inflation and inflation is subdued right now. But notice how the Fed has changed its language about policy -- starting with a near-depression moving to declining growth and now to economic recovery. Is the Fed addicted to expansionary policy? Will the next stage include rationalizing expansionary monetary policy so long as the economy has not reached its previous peak level? Or maybe they will keep pushing in money until economic growth averages the rate it takes to gain full employment? Where does it end?

Why would I care? For two reasons -- the current policy is going to make things worse now and will lead to higher inflation in the future. It will make things worse now because it creates more uncertainty for investors without any remedial value. The patient is getting better but the doctor wants to give him even more drugs because he isn't healing fast enough. Interest rates are very low -- does the the Fed really think that pushing them a little lower is going to cause us to go out and buy a new car? Will firms suddenly run to the bank to borrow money so they can build more plants? I don't think so. This new policy message would make me wonder if the economy is ever going to recover. I'd continue to save, pay off debts, and drink cheap whiskey. It will create more inflation down the road for obvious reasons. There is no way that the Fed is going to pull out money quick enough given the huge volume outstanding.

Why did the Fed make this statement this week? What good might it have accomplished? I simply don't get it. Do you?

Thursday, September 16, 2010

Finger in the Dike - Geithner and the Big Three team up for Nothing

I had planned a follow up to my Myopic Squirrel post next, but I just can't sit around and eat Kimche today. So let me break with tradition and write a short piece so I can get on with my day. Most of the headlines right now focus on China as a currency manipulator and are encouraging our enlightened government to finally do something about China. But guess what -- all this protectionist mumbo jumbo is exactly like the stimulus policy, the government bailouts and the toothless financial reform -- they amount to a finger in a dike. Worse than that -- they amount to a finger in the famous Dutch dike as a tsunami races to Den Haag.

Yes, yes, yes -- CHINA IS A CURRENCY MANIPULATOR. Geez, how long have we known this? Did we just discover it? Do we have a chance in Hades of really changing their policy? Is China not the giant in the neighborhood who is going to get stronger and stronger? Is there something strange about the timing of all this? As the government grabs at every possible last minute last ditch effort to invigorate a recovering economy, is this not just one more example of something stupid that appeals only to populist and hateful and envious Americans?

And you know what the bad thing is about all this misdirected energy? The bad thing is that it confuses people about the best ways to deal with the impacts of globalization. The tsunami  involves more than China -- if you are paying attention you know that China is only one of many countries who threaten top compete more vigorously with US firms. What was announced by EU today? They have consummated the EU/Korea Free Trade Agreement. We talked about working hard at FTAs but the truth is that our government would rather reach for the protectionist/populist card than do the hard work of negotiating and implementing a FTA.

It is easy to make eloquent speeches pointing to China as a currency manipulator. But you know what? Even if China let its currency appreciate -- it would not be a very good thing for anyone. We have a trade deficit in the USA because we spend so much and save so little. We have a trade deficit because other countries save a lot and spend a little. To think that fiery rhetoric and currency changes are going to do anything but create small, annoying, and temporary impacts is to be putting your finger in a small hole in a large dike that is bracing  for a 200 foot wall of churning water. Now I can go eat my kimche.

Monday, September 13, 2010

The Myopic Squirrel and $7 trillion worth of Missing Nuts

It is well-known that a major part of our difficulties today is that like the myopic squirrel, we ate all the nuts in the Fall and didn’t put enough away for the Winter. In other words, residents of the US spent like there was no tomorrow. The spending and the leverage that accompanied it contributed to problems in real estate which spread to the financial sector and then to Main Street. Did we really spend thatmuch? What will it take to restore some balance?

I deal with those questions in this blog. It is sobering to see what Karma has wrought. Can we trim the US consumer’s appetite by $840 billion per year in the coming decade? It won’t be easy but that’s what I think it will take to return to something normal. My calculation is that the US household would have to trim its annual consumption by approximately 42 billion bottles of Jack Daniels. While that seems tough, another calculation finds that if there are approximately 300 million people in the US, then per capita consumer spending would have to fall by about $2,700 per year.

To draw these conclusions I found data on the website of the Bureau of Economic Analysis – http://www.bea.gov/ . I chose to use real (chain-weighted) GDP and Personal Consumption Expenditures (RGDP, RPCE). Using real figures means that the Commerce Department has removed price change from these figures. To examine how consumer spending changed over time, I look at both the value of the amount of RPCE as well as its share of GDP (Share=(RPCE/RGDP)*100). For the year 2009, RGDP was $12.9 trillion. RPCE in the same year was 71% of that amount, or $9.2 trillion. RPCE includes the spending in the US on consumer durable goods (like cars, and furniture), nondurable consumer goods (like food and clothing), and consumer services (like financial transactions and transportation). RPCE does not count goods or services that businesses buy (like plant construction business computers) nor does it count goods and services purchased by foreigners or the government. It also does not include housing construction. Because of the latter, it does not include any of the spending of households on new houses or condominiums. Clearly, if I added the latter, the numbers would get bigger.

So what about this 71% figure for 2009? The table below shows the average of Share over selected periods of time. Notice that for the 18 year time period stretching from after World War II until 1963, Share was a little less than 63%. In the next 16 years – call this from President LBJ to Carter – the ratio increased to about 64%. Share in the 1980s rose to 66%, in the 1990s to 67% and then the last decade it averaged about 70%. At the end of that period it hung in at 71%. Very clearly, household spending has not only increased in absolute terms but it has become an ever larger part of the nation’s output and income – that is, RPCE has been growing much faster than RGDP.

Share of Real PCE to Real GDP for selected time periods from 1946 to 2009
46-63
64-79
80-89
90-99
00-09
62.53
63.91
65.90
66.63
69.63

Okay – so Share is rising, but what else can we say? Let’s make a big assumption about normality. Let’s take the 44 year period from 1946 to 1989 as a norm. Share averaged about 64% during that time. Let’s calculate how much RPCE would have been IF SHARE HAD REMAINED AT 64% IN THE FINAL 20 YEARS. Applying the normal Share of 64% to the years between 1990 and 2009 gives us a normal RPCE estimate of about $8.2 trillion in 2009. The actual RPCE in that year was $9.2 trillion. Subtracting the normal estimate from the actual value, we find that above-normal RPCE was about $910 billion dollars in 2009. Notice that in terms of 2009 figures, RPCE was about 10% higher than if SHARE has been normal. That is, if we want RPCE to return to a more normal share of the national economy, consumers should have spent about 10% less than they did in 2009.

That’s just one year. What if we look at the whole decade from 2000 to 2009? The total RGDP produced over the period was $123.2 trillion. RPCE totaled $85.8 trillion. If RPCE Share was 64% during the whole 10 years, RPCE would have summed to $78.8 trillion – or about $7 trillion less than what was actually spent. In other words – households spent $7 trillion more than normal for a decade. Now that’s starting to look like money! US consumers overspent more than half of a full year’s RGDP in the last 10 years.
What about the future? I estimate that at current trends we will overspend approximately $8.4 trillion in the next 10 years from 2010 to 2019. In other words, we need to trim spending by roughly $840 billion per year for the next 10 years to restore the PCE Ratio to 64% of Real GDP. During that time period RGDP will average $14.7 trillion per year (if it grows at the same rate as the past decade – a lowly 2% per year). If Share remains at 71% then Real PCE will average $10.3 trillion per year. With a normal Share of 64%, Real PCE would average $9.4 trillion. Thus over-consumption would average approximately $840 billion per year from 2010 to 2019.

Let’s add an important perspective. Cutting out this $840 billion each year from 2010 to 2019 does not mean that RPCE has to decline. What it says is that as a nation if we want to return the share of consumer spending back to something normal, then we will have to increase our spending at a lower rate. Notice that should RPCE grow at a more normal rate it will average about $9.4 trillion per year; it will GROW! But it must grow by somewhat less than the $10.3 trillion average if Share is to return to some sense of normalcy.
You can’t have your Jack Daniels and drink it too. We have a clear choice. We can continue to spend like a drunken hooligan or we can try to put our house back in order. Chopping $840 billion per year out of consumer spending will not be easy – noting that if we apply this same analysis to residential construction we will have to tighten the future belt even more – and the result will be slower growth of both output and employment. But not tightening has its price too. Clearly all this spending reduces the nation’s saving and its ability – like the squirrel – to do what’s best for the future. There is no way to return to normal economic health without a return to normal spending. Let’s get on with it.  To set an example, I had breakfast this morning without my usual JD.

Tuesday, September 7, 2010

Stuck in Macroeconomic Purgatory

I got a lot of nice comments about my Lilliputians post. The comments made me think more about why the two parties just can’t seem to face up to current economic issues in the way many of us would like to see. Unlike some of my other posts, this one takes me out of my comfort zone and into what I would call pure conjecture. This is the kind of stuff one talks about in the bar after having one too many JDs.

In my last post I conjectured that it might be better now to view our economic issues as an interrelated set of challenges that would be better handled as a single set rather than in piecemeal fashion. I argued that both parties could get plenty of credit by taking a more holistic approach and that the resulting policies would be an improvement of what we have been seeing lately. While liberals might be partially pleased with recent progress in some policies (In particular healthcare, stimulus, and financial reform) much of what was legislated was done without conservative support and the path forward with respect to those and other policies now seems even harder to travel. While much might be decided by the coming November elections, there is no guarantee that this will produce anything beyond a stalemate.

So not much is going to change and we seem stuck with politicians who seem more concerned with pleasing the extreme wings of their parties than with solving our pressing economic problems. This seems crazy and wrong since no party is going to have the muscle or support to make the compromises that will produce the right kinds of policies—those that address the cause and effect of the issues.

The question then is why we are stuck in Macroeconomic Purgatory. Here is where I take a big gulp of JD and move ahead unsteadily. My conjecture is that none of these politicians took Econ 101 from Art Benavie at the University of North Carolina in Chapel Hill. I was very lucky to have been accepted into the PhD program in Economics at UNC in 1973. I was a teaching assistant for Prof. Benavie and learned a lot from listening to his lectures to freshmen. I learned a lot from him (as well as from Dick Froyen, Roger Waud, and the many other folks involved with the Macro Seminar) but one thing that stood out was the point that policies for income redistribution should be handled separately from those of macroeconomic efficiency and growth. I believe this is a point that Milton Friedman also articulated and espoused. Regardless of where it originated, Prof. Benavie made it come alive in the classroom in Chapel Hill. It all seemed so clear. There was one axiom – you cannot have an economic issue or policy without the problem or the policy having an implication for income redistribution. Benavie’s conclusion was that income distribution should to be treated separately from other issues.

Let me try to give an example that relates to macroeconomics. Macro is the study of the economy of a nation or region. It does not seek to model or explain the behaviors of individual persons or sectors – rather it sees the economy as a whole. So let’s suppose the nation has high unemployment or slow growth. The NATION, therefore, is operating inefficiently. The MACRO ISSUE is that the system is not working as it should or could. The MACRO ISSUE is that workers and the goods and services they make are less than the amounts that ought to be hired and produced. But notice – the story doesn’t end there. The recession also has uneven impacts on persons and sectors. Perhaps the white goods market is more negatively impacted than others. Maybe the Northeast is hurting more than the South. Low income persons may be impacted more than those with higher incomes.

The main point here is that Macro problems always come with unequal and negative impacts on various persons, sectors, regions, etc. BUT MACRO POLICIES ARE ALWAYS DESIGNED TO ADDRESS THE MACRO PROBLEMS. MACRO POLICIES are not designed to deal with the numerous and myriad individual impacts of recessions.

Hearing this you might retort – that’s exactly what’s wrong with macro. How can you not care about all these uneven impacts on people and companies and sectors and so on? But I would snort this retort – a chain saw is a great tool to bring down a dead tree. A chain saw kicks butt when it comes to bringing down a tree. But if you use your chain saw to provide the missing shade or to replace the beauty of the tree, you might be barking up the wrong tree. Sorry – I just couldn’t help myself. But you see the point. To replace the shade provided by the tree – you might be better off with a shovel to dig a hole for another tree. To replace the beauty of the tree you might want to paint the new lovely lawn flamingos you purchased at the limestone store.

You can care a lot about the missing shade and the loss of beauty but if the tree is dead, then you need a tool designed to deal with that problem. You can use other tools for the shade/beauty issue. Similarly in macro, you need macro tools for the recessionary conditions – and other policies and tools for the micro issues. And the traditional MACRO TOOLS are notoriously not designed for the many micro problems – while they are, like the shovel, focused on one problem -- remediating MACRO PROBLEMS.

When I speak of the traditional MACRO TOOLS I specifically refer to monetary and fiscal policy. Since Keynes’ ideas were first cast into a modern macro model by Sir John Hicks and others – the profession has articulated (and debated) using monetary and fiscal policy to target real GDP and employment. These tools can’t do everything. Monetary and fiscal policy do not guarantee any level of effectiveness at moving real GDP or employment – just as a particular chain saw might not always take down the tree. But at least you know it is the right kind of tool for the problem. Most economists would agree, however, that monetary and fiscal policy are NOT designed or appropriate for solving the energy crisis, making American an export dynamo, reducing poverty, or saving education. We view other tools as being superior for those problems.

Congress apparently never got the message – because we hold macro policy hostage to other issues – especially income distribution. Prof Benavie would say – use a Macro Policy for the recession. Then check and see how that might impact income distribution. If income distribution is worsened by the Macro Policy, then design a specific policy to solve that issue. Don’t let the income distribution ramifications cause you to alter the Macro Policy. If you want to do something about incomes of the poor or the middle class – don’t use a chain saw or Macro Policy – use a policy specifically designed to help people move up in the income distribution..

But notice what we argue about tirelessly. Should the Bush-era tax cuts for the rich be extended? Should the Fed expand its program to buy mortgage securities so rates on mortgages will be driven lower and funds be made more available to people who otherwise could not buy houses? Should unemployment benefits be extended for months to provide income for a group measuring probably less than 5% of the US population? Should we direct extra stimulus spending to poor people on Medicaid? The list goes on and on.

Notice that I am not denigrating the need to have policies designed to improve the distribution of income. What I am saying is that Macro Policy cannot and should not solve income distribution problems. If we want to raise GDP or employment let’s debate Macro Policy on its Macro Merits. If we want to improve the income distribution, let’s have debates and legislation designed for that. Failing to understand this simple point means that it is going to be next to impossible to get good policy. It is much too easy for any populist politician (is that redundant?) to use income distribution as the excuse to not stand behind good macro policy. There will always be compromises in policy but watering down a macro policy to achieve income distribution goals is not a positive compromise since it means less than desirable policies for economic growth and income distribution. Preferable would be simultaneous passage of separate and specific policies designed for macro and income distribution. As I suggested above, this would imply a holistic approach to policy – not a sequential and piecemeal approach. As a result, instead of getting a nice burger and fries, we will be presented with mush.

Monday, August 30, 2010

Don’t Pick- up that $100 bill. It isn’t really there. Defending Efficient Markets

A guy sees a $100 bill on the sidewalk and walks right by it. A Keynesian comes up to him and asks him why he didn’t pick it up. The guy answers that he believes in the Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) – and the bill must not be real or someone else would have already picked it up! This joke is a real knee-slapper for academics. It is meant to demean the EMH. This not only shows why academics are not allowed to mingle with normal people but it also irks me that my fellow academics have too much fun beating a straw horse.

Why defend the EMH?  One reason is because it is 95 degrees and Betty will have me doing tasks in the back yard if I don’t pretend to be doing something in my nice cool basement office/laundry room/ junk room.  The other reason is that it needs defending from people who would use this as part of their rejection of markets and capitalism. Some experts believe that our recent financial crisis proves the EMH is wrong.  Even worse, it gives them a high horse to preach for more stimulus and more regulation.  So I would like to give them a little piece of what is left of my mind.

Before getting into the particulars we should take a step back and think about the whole idea of learning and hypotheses. You don’t have to have a PhD  to see the importance of hypotheses. As a young parent you believe that you should keep a close eye on your two-year-old. You have a hypothesis that if you completely ignore your child, a problem could arise – perhaps even something terrible could happen. I remember when we once saw our neighbor’s child on the roof of their house. They blinked one minute and somehow he was on the roof. It scared the crap out of all of us. Hypotheses like this one lead to action items or policy prescriptions. If the hypothesis is true, then you need to have rules for vigilance. You need to be a very active parent. We usually frown on leashes for children but I know of some parents who have resorted to such things.

Financial economists have a hypothesis about the prices of assets like stocks and bonds – and houses. The hypothesis states that the price you observe in the market for GM stock or for the average of all stocks is the result of buyers and sellers searching for all the relevant information, analyzing it, and then using it in their sales and purchases. This is not very sophisticated stuff. It just says we are not a bunch of LAZY LOSERS. Most of us – before we buy a refrigerator or a car or a share of stock – try to figure out what it is worth or at least find some information that would support our buying the item at a particular place and time. Suppose you do a little research and you are ready to buy the latest I-Phone when your mother comes in and says she heard that I-Phones cause pimples. But the Droid does not cause pimples… So you look in the mirror and pop a few – and then make your decision based on all the information.

This is not a crazy hypothesis to say that people try to buy as well as they can! Would you rather assume that most people are really lazy and ignorant and dumb and they just buy stuff regardless of price or other relevant information? I hope not. My father would spin in his urn.
Okay – so people – both buyers and sellers – gather and utilize information when trading various assets. This implies that the current market price, which is determined by the interactions of buyers and sellers, REFLECTS THE STATE OF RELEVANT EXISTING INFORMATION. It makes no sense that people would totally ignore pertinent information that was out there.

Basically this is what the EMH says – that current prices embody current information. It also implies that it is difficult for someone to make gains in the market that are not available to everyone else. If prices register all the current information, then it is difficult for one person to profit from the information.  If the EMH is true, it stands to reason that it is hard to “beat the market”. EMH friends advise me that I should buy an index fund and just hold it. Trying to pick individual stocks and to time the market (buy low and sell high) is virtually impossible if information is abundant.

Another implication of the EMH is that government intervention into markets is unnecessary. If prices are being driven by information flows about fundamental factors, then prices are playing their appropriate roles in a market system. Consider the recent bubble in asset prices. At the time Alan Greenspan did not think the Fed could or should do anything about rapidly rising housing and stock prices. Presently the government doesn’t talk much about a bond price bubble. Why? Because Greenspan and Bernanke believe that asset prices are being determined by fundamental factors.  They may not like these fundamental factors but by their very nature they are not easy to change or remediate with policy.

But notice that if the EMH is wrong, then perhaps phantoms or something or someone terrible is behind price changes and something should be done about it.  This creates a stronger role for government intervention – if the EMH is false. So is it true or not?

One piece of information being used these days is to point to Hedge Funds and to acknowledge that some of them have made a ton of money choosing stocks and timing the market. If you have not already, you should read Sebastian Mallaby’s “More Money than God”.  But just because there are examples of Hedge Funds or other investors who made a lot of money, this does not necessarily disprove EMH. How many Hedge Funds lost money trying to pick stocks and time markets? How many funds made a lot of money trading only to eventually lose it using the very same models and approaches? All it takes is a few very successful and very lucky pickers to get the attention of the press. A few successes do not, however, make a rule. If 10,000 monkeys are given computers and 10 monkeys print out the line – Davidson should receive a Nobel Prize – then would you nominate me for the award next year?   Hopefully the outputs of the 9,990 monkeys would have some sway with you.

Furthermore, the EMH never said that it is impossible for some people to know more than others for a time and it never said it was impossible for unscrupulous people to contrive means to fool the public. The EMH only says that ability to corner the market on information should not go on forever and once information becomes public prices will reflect fundamental forces.  
Finally, there is the paradox that if EMH is true, how is it possible that asset price changes could look so much like bubbles? You have heard all the stories of rapid price appreciation – and people wondering just how long it would keep up. In the meantime, people were buying houses and stocks at prices that seemed drastically out of line with reality. How can a story about rationality and efficiency explain buying $100,000 condos for $300,000?

The answer lies in what you consider to be the appropriate price. Should the appropriate market price consider future expectations?  You are considering buying a nice condo. Last year similar condos were selling for $100,000. Today you learn that oil has been discovered on the property and all condo owners are expected to receive $500,000 in future royalties. What would you pay for that condo today? That lovely little property that was worth $100,000 yesterday is worth more like $600,000 today. Is that irrational? That’s a big change—but it can be explained by expectations about the future. What would the condo be worth if scientists found that the property was being built on top of a former electronic factory and that the land was giving off cancerous fumes?

I hope you are getting the point that the EMH is perfectly compatible with extreme changes in price. Now, let’s apply this to recent events. There were plenty of reasons to explain why housing and stock prices were rising before 2008. No one can know the future so there were many thoughtful discussions that led many people to conclude that the fast pace of house and stock prices made some sense. There were also many people warning that the prices could not sustain such a rapid pace. All opinions were out in the public and all we can say in retrospect is that people operated with an expectation that prices would continue to rise. That expectation made more people willing to buy and willing to buy at a higher price. The expectations were self-fulfilling. At least they were until the correction came. While this suggests that bubbles do pop or corrections do come – this does not in any way disparage the EMH. EMH simply says people use information in transactions. When expectations about the future are strongly and passionately held – this is part of the information. Those prices that today seem so out of pace with reality – were efficient guesses three years ago. They used all the information.

Today we have a different set of expectations and a different and depressed level of prices. These are efficient prices for today’s information. And this leads us to the final point – what can or what should be done. Let’s not throw away the EMH – rather let’s use it to decide what to do. It seems to me that what went wrong were two things. First, regulators didn’t do their jobs. The whole credit chain fell apart as EVERYONE justified their expectations by leveraging in dangerous and illegal ways.  And the regulators let them. Second, policymakers helped to sustain the fundamental factors that led to a desire for more leverage and for higher asset price inflation. Greenspan didn’t see how low policy-induced interest rates induced a desire to take more risk in markets.  The Fed stoked the fires.  And Fannie/Freddie fanned the flames.

Now the expectations are that prices will continue to fall. That means there is a good way and a bad way for policymakers to act now. The bad way is to try to grease the wheels of credit expansion. That just gets up back into the same garlic pickle.  The good way is to approach the fundamentals. People will believe that the worst is over when policymakers earnestly address what was wrong. To do this they need to do sensible things that reduce our need to leverage ourselves beyond our ability to pay.  Regulation and policy should be addressed to sensible use of borrowing by the government and the private sector. Until they do that it is hard to see an end to the current economic slowdown. Now where did that $100 bill go? 

Monday, August 23, 2010

Lilliputians at the helm -- Why we can’t escape this recession

I heard this joke a long time ago – A guy is driving his car in the mountains. As he heads into a sharp turn a person standing next to the road yells to him – “Pig”. The driver is incensed and yells back at him “Jerk”. Immediately after turning the corner he runs right into a pig in the road.

This joke reminds me of our political leadership. They seem to have no ability to communicate. It seems to me that the problem is worse now but maybe it has always been that way. I don’t know but it is making me more and more irritable!

Since my life has been spent thinking about macroeconomics, it amazes me how the current debates about economic stimulus get us nowhere.  Even the pace of the recovery has become politicized. Republicans seem to want the economy to double-dip so they can point their fingers at the Democrat’s whose stimulus policies did not work. Democrats want the recovery to look good but not good enough to stave off another round or two of stimulus.

While economists also join the usual partisan bickering we are inflicted by our inability to say anything that the politicians seem to understand.  Economists are a lot like meteorologists during hurricane season. We have a lot of theory and a lot of data but we still make a lot of errors! When we try to explain our reasoning, the average politician or TV viewer heads to the kitchen for another slice of black forest cherry cake with vanilla ice cream.  Don’t say all that jibberish! Just tell me if a hurricane is going to hit my house! And when!
The lucky thing for meteorologists is that politicians don’t usually act on hurricane predictions!  So we economists duke it out in the Wall Street Journal, the Financial Times, and Fox News.  I knew that would wake-up some of you! J    And yet, the politicians keep saying inane things and then VOTING on real policies that will affect most of us from now until Hell freezes over.

So I am going to give both sides a little advice. First, in all likelihood we are not headed for either a pure capitalist or socialist state in the near future. This is not about extreme states – it is about the best way to permanently exit a recession and a way to return the unemployment rate to something more normal. SO SHUT-UP YOUR SLOGANS AND QUIT CALLING EACH OTHER NAMES. 

Second, this recession IS different. It is not only deep and enduring but it is the result of a perfect storm of myriad forces that took some time to manifest and will take some time to heal – with or without brilliant policy. My neighbor had serious heart surgery recently. He is on the road to recovery but he knows that not every day will be a good one. There will be ups and downs. He must be patient. Healing will take a while. Why then do our politicians pounce on every bounce in the economy – ready to declare a horrible or beautiful new course of policy? Geez guys and gals – the recovery is not going to be smooth or linear. TAKE A BIG BREATHE.  You have an unprecedented amount of stimulus working in the system – don’t add more!

Third – talk to each other. You guys are like rival gangs at a biker bar. The second Big Moe’s elbow accidentally barely scrapes Hot Mary’s elegantly sculptured boob tattoo of a snake eating the head of a winged dinosaur, all hell breaks out.  As soon as Mary screams the Purple Devils and Mauling Marauders weapon-up and go to their respective corners to prepare for the battle. The Democrats are armed with silly slogans about multipliers and a heart full of compassion for the unemployed while the Republicans load up on Barro’s version of rational expectations and strongly expressed love for fiduciary responsibility. You don’t talk to the enemy during the war – you lob stupid bombs at each other until the other finally gives up – i.e. loses the election.

One must wonder if our politicians are not like proverbial warriors who live only for the fight. My guess is that given the special nature of this recession it is going to take some real compromises to get this thing fixed. Consider the compromise story.  Policy has already and will continue to address all of the following issues– stabilizing aggregate demand, financing the aging of the population, correcting imbalances in the distribution of income, regulating the financial sector, reforming healthcare, widening access to green energy, a war on terrorism, immigration policy, and more. It seems to me that a more overt recognition of the complexity of these issues warrants significant compromise on both sides. Yet instead of viewing the whole policy scene as an opportunity for both parties to improve the country, they take each issue piecemeal and try to win the hearts and minds of the voters bit by bit. Surely with all these opportunities for legislation, there is plenty of room for give and take. Both sides could declare victory. But so far, our warriors seem to relish in the fight and grapple for wins on virtually every point of contention. Meanwhile we languish in a seemingly never-ending economic limbo as our politicians play dueling banjos.

Why does common sense seem so out of line with what we observe from our politicians? I think it is because we have really big issues right now and we have really small politicians. While I like today’s movements towards more transparency, right now I long for the good old days when politicians went behind closed doors, drank brandy and smoked cigars, and made deals.  Imagine the scene -- Obama taps his ash, leans across the table and tells John Boehner – I’ll give you two corporate income tax reductions for one extension of job benefits. John smiles and rubs his knee against Nancy Pelosi’s throbbing thigh and says, Okay Nancy, throw in a reduction in capital gains tax and I’ll not only go with the unemployment extension but I’ll give you a new tax on imported oil. Nancy pours her Armenian cognac in John’s lap and says it all sounds good so long as we throw in a few more dollars for education.

Okay, so I drink while I write. But you get the point. We need a new crop of politicians – if you don’t like what you see, then why do you stick with the idea that these bozos in both parties are there to help us? These folks are not helping us and we need to show them the door. We need some political leaders who will stop being warriors and try becoming statesmen. This is a very challenging time. We need better.  

Monday, August 16, 2010

China is #2. China is #99. What should I think?

Today Bloomberg.com published a small article announcing – ta da – that China has overtaken Japan with the second largest GDP in the world, second only to the -  ta da – the USA. We’re number 1, we’re #1. Do the wave now.

Anyway, in the case of China, the numbers are very interesting. For example, the comparison reported today has both China and Japan at about $5 trillion in Gross Domestic Product.

Note that when you compare the GDP across countries, you have to put all country amounts into one currency. This currency is usually the dollar. So the $5 trillion is the result of taking the country’s GDP in its own currency (yen or yuan) and using current exchange rates to convert to dollars. That sounds straightforward enough were it not for the fact that today’s exchange rate might be a little weird. That is, today’s exchange rate might not truly represent the  fundamental market forces that “ought to move it in one direction or another.” Or one might say the exchange rate is out of long-term equilibrium. So being weird they don’t trust it and then put it in jail. Economist’s jail, that is.

With the current exchange rate in jail, experts create a substitute that better reflects fundamental market forces – or at least it better represents changes in relative country prices. If China has a cost advantage and that makes its traded goods prices more competitive than other countries, this leads to a Chinese trade surplus. 
Theory suggests that the value of the yuan should rise to clear that surplus. Thus, an economist would say that the equilibrium value of the yuan is really higher than today’s market value. They call this the PPP (purchasing power parity) exchange rate. I hate to say PPP because every time I type PPP I have to run upstairs to the bathroom. But that’s an old man thing so don’t get off track here.

When we use the PPP estimate of GDP to compare countries, China has been #2 for quite a while.  Go to Wikipedia to see that China’s GDP at PPP is double that of Japan’s. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)  So while PPP does not change the ranking for Japan and China – it does give a very different picture – in one case the GDPs are the same – in the other case China’s is double that of Japan.

Okay – so one more statistic. Wikipedia also has a table with GDP at PPP per capita. We know China has a lot more people than Japan – so let’s see what happens when we ask how well the average person is doing. In that table, the US comes in 6th, Japan is 23rd, and China is 99th. Yes, China was right behind economic super powers Guyana and Nimibia. Hmmm. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_per_capita
So what does all this mean? I don’t really know. Notice how I made this post really short. It would take a very long post to discuss all the economic, political, and astro-physical implications of all this. So I will leave it to my wacko friends to say more.

But I will say this. There are many dimensions to a country’s economic size or might. Naturally a country with the world’s largest population should have a large GDP. But how strong can a country be if its average citizen is extremely poor? And in the case of China, a lot of the goods produced and measured in GDP go elsewhere – so what the average citizen living in China gets is even lower than the reported GDP figures. Clearly it makes sense that the Chinese government would want to improve per capita GDP.  With so many people, this will only push China farther up the ranks in terms of its total GDP produced. To think that a country with roughly four times the population of the US would forever be behind in terms of GDP simply makes no sense. So you go girl!

Finally one more point – I know there are many, many errors in cross country measurement. You can’t really compare the price of oxen in China to those in the US. There are also many problems in determining the value of the PPP exchange rate. But don’t let those measurement problems deter you from my main message in this post. China is a large, poor country with designs to be richer. As they get richer per capita, they will gradually approach and then exceed the GDP of the US.  But they have an even longer way to go before the average person in China will enjoy the income, wealth, and economic freedoms that we have in the US. 

Friday, August 6, 2010

Fairy Tales Can Come True. It can happen to you….blah blah blah

I was going to take the day off but then I read some of the news and if there ever was a time to write a blog post – it has to be today.

One of the best parts of my life was reading bedtime stories to my kids. Now they read them to me. Ha ha. Just kidding. But I did love reading to them. So it occurred to me that some of the fairy tales I am reading now in the press will have a bigger effect on them than Dr. Seuss or the Man in the Yellow Hat.
Fairy tale #1. A matter-of-fact story came out today about Medicare and Social Security funding and how the latter was fine until 2037. The story didn’t use Al Gore’s memorable term, Lock Box, but it did re-conjure-up that illusion. You know what a lock box is, right? Basically it is a physical thing that keeps money in it so that when bills come due you can pay them. Or it can be a physical thing that you bury in your backyard and tell your kids to dig it up when you die. Your kids, not having had a very good education in our failing public schools, will believe that old Dad and Mom have placed some very valuable items in there. Once they dig up the box and clear away the dirt – they will be rich!

Anyway, that’s what most of us think is a lock box. Al Gore made the mistake of likening the balances in the Social Security Trust Funds to a lock box. And that is why Al Gore had to sit in the corner and eat cold porridge. Anyway, imagine that your son digs up your lock box – opens it up – and finds a piece of paper in it. The paper contains a note that says, “honey, we spent all the money on Cognac and we would recommend that you ask your sister for a loan. We do love you very much.”

You think I am kidding. I think not. This year. THIS YEAR the social security tax revenues are not large enough to pay the beneficiaries (old helpless creatures who need Cognac). But the Social Security Trust Fund (SSTF) will make up the difference. What is the SSTF? A large pile of ten dollar bills? Is it a bunch of gold? HA HA – I think not. It is a bunch of paper that means the Federal Government must pay back what it borrowed in the past from the SSTF. The Federal government puts money back into the SSTF – and then they pay it to the retirees. Where does the Federal Government get the money when it already has a very large deficit? It gets it from raising your taxes! There is nothing in the lock box except a note that says the government promises to makes you charge higher taxes! Even worse, the amount in the SSTF – the amount the government borrowed from it over many years – will run out in 2037. The lock box will not only not have money in it – it won’t even have any more I-owe-yous. This means that your taxes will go up more and more and more as we approach 2037. My son will be approximately my age in 2037.

Fairy Tale #2. It was announced that President Obama does not want to take his latest brainy remedy for unemployment through Congress. Instead he can make a Presidential mandate that allows the Fannie/Freddie twins to spit smoke and fire. Or at least Fannie/Freddie will be able to give more mortgages to people without having to deal with all that silly paperwork. What a burden for bankers to ask embarrassing questions like – “could you ever from now to eternity pay us back one red cent you are borrowing for this Italian villa that was recently transported and reconstructed brick by brick in Ellettsville IN?

Okay – we’d love to see people buying more houses. That would be good for the economy. Homes would be built, developers would be able to go on Rhine Cruises, and more workers would get jobs. But geez you guys, how much does the government need to do beyond the lowest mortgage interest rates since Hugh Hefner was a baby? And didn’t the current crisis result mostly from subprime housing loans? Why on this earth would our president want to go down that path again? Why? Because of Fairy Tale #2. He does not have to listen to congressmen wail about budget deficits and debt. Future Fannie and Freddie liabilities can be increased infinitely today without the numbers actually showing up in the official government budget figures. Of course we know that granting loans without scrutiny will lead to government funding of the bad loans – and that will eventually show up in the budget. But these numbers will not be recorded today nor will they show up before Halloween.

THE KING HAS NO CLOTHES, THEY SCREAMED! But it is just a fairy tale. There is a lock box and we shouldn’t worry about social security. We can fix the economy by giving people low-interest loans that do not have to be paid back by the borrowers. I can lose 100 pounds of unwanted fat by taking the latest pill.
Good night kids. Sleep tight and don’t let the bed bugs bite.

Tuesday, August 3, 2010

Quarter 2 Real GDP – Why does the press prefer to look through mud-colored glasses?

The second quarter Real GDP figure was announced last week and as usual it got a lot of attention. There were many stories written and the general tone of most of them was worrisome – the 2.4% annualized rate of growth in real GDP from the first quarter to the second quarter of 2010, was low for two reasons – it was lower than the 3.7% growth in the first quarter and it was lower than experts predicted.

Of course, that is NOT what many people wanted to hear. It reinforced the idea that we might be headed toward a double dip recession (why is a double dip good for ice cream but not for the economy?) or deflation. The Keynesians shouted – “I told you so” – and many articles were written to the effect that we need even more monetary and fiscal stimulus. All this was based pretty much on one number for one quarter! It’s a little like winning one hand at Black Jack and then emptying your checking account so that you can bet your whole fortune on your sure-to-come gambling earnings!

To be fair, there were a lot of articles written and not all of them read like a Keynesian recruitment poster. So let me try to bring in some other facts that put the 2.4% number in a broader and more positive context. If you go to the following link you can get enough GDP data to build an Egyptian pyramid. http://bea.gov/national/index.htm#gdp

First, the 2.4% was the fourth consecutive quarter of positive growth in real GDP. That means a full year of growth since Q3 2009.

Second, real GDP statistics are revised many times. So the 2.4% is not the last word on Q2 of 2010. To emphasize that this first look at the number is based on incomplete information, it is officially called the Advance Estimate. Q1 2010 real GDP got revised upward from 2.7% to 3.7%. Wowee. That’s a big revision. I hate to tell you this, but the last revision to Q2 2010 will come about five years from now. REALLY. I am not fooling. Before then, you will see at least three updates – in one quarter, two quarters, and in one year. So stay tuned to learn more about Q2 2010.So people were oooing and ahhhing and making policy suggestions based on a number that isn’t much better than a lottery ticket.

Third, you can see a lot of very specific data if you go to the above site and download data tables. For example, we are very concerned about personal consumption spending (PCE). You will see that PCE rose by 1.6% in Q2. That is exactly how much PCE rose – an average of 1.6% per year – during the previous three quarters. So with respect to PCE, it was growing at the same rate as it had been during the recovery. I know we want to it grow faster – but there was no slowdown evident in Q2 PCE.

Growth in consumer spending on services – the largest component of PCE – had it fastest growth in several years. Geez I guess they forgot to mention that in their ugly little story. PCE in real annual dollars was about $9.2 trillion in Q2 and PCE-Services spending was about $6.0 trillion. So PCE-Services is roughly two-thirds of all PCE. That makes it almost half of all of real GDP! Note that consumer spending on durable goods was only about $1.2 trillion in comparison. It is fine to worry about the automobile industry – but we should not let the rear view mirror get in the way of watching spending on consumer services.

What else? One major reason that real GDP slowed a bit in the fourth quarter has to do with how we account for imports. GDP is a measure of domestic production. Because imported goods are not produced in the US, they have to be netted out – subtracted from the GDP sales figures. Imports of goods rose by 35.4% on an annualized basis in Q2. So that explains a lot of why real GDP slowed. But note that while it subtracts from output – it does show a resumption of spending. It shows some optimism about future spending. Of course, if all we do is buy imports and do not increase our spending on domestically produced goods and services, this will not help to increase future real GDP.

Missing in some of these articles was an explanation of residential spending – which rose by 27.9% in Q2. Hmmm – and that was only the second quarter that such an increase occurred in several years. Spending on the production of new residences – spending on newly built houses, apartment buildings, condos, etc – fell by 12.3% in Q1 and by 0.8% in Q4 2009. Someone should have made a big noise about this!!!! But I guess it didn’t fit in with their stupid sky is falling story. Supporting a picture of rising construction spending is that Q2 was the first time that spending on business structures (plant, office buildings, etc) showed any growth in years. It grew by 5.2% in Q2.

Part of the good growth story was a 14.1% growth in exports of goods and a 21.9% growth in business spending on equipment and software.

Some of our economist friends and their buddies in the press saw a glass of bourbon sitting on the bar. They preferred to see it as half empty and unworthy of drinking. While this was no batch of Pappy Van Winkle, it was a glass of hooch worth drinking. It is a shame that even a routine data announcement has to be tainted by such incomplete and biased analysis.